h hoge.gg
Subscribe
BTC$67,432.18+2.34%ETH$3,521.44+1.08%SOL$178.62-0.62%BNB$612.30+0.41%XRP$0.6234-0.18%ADA$0.4521+3.12%DOGE$0.1623+1.86%AVAX$38.71-1.24%LINK$17.84+0.92%HOGE$0.00004120+4.21%
BTC$67,432.18+2.34%ETH$3,521.44+1.08%SOL$178.62-0.62%BNB$612.30+0.41%XRP$0.6234-0.18%ADA$0.4521+3.12%DOGE$0.1623+1.86%AVAX$38.71-1.24%LINK$17.84+0.92%HOGE$0.00004120+4.21%
● Regulation & Policy

How Crypto ETFs Get Approved Without a Rulebook

US spot crypto ETFs were built on exemptions and delegated orders, not a formal rulebook. At a 19 November Senate hearing, the SEC's own two nominees split over whether that should finally change.

On the morning of 19 November 2026, in Room 538 of the Dirksen Senate Office Building, two people who may soon help run the agency that approves crypto exchange-traded funds sat at a witness table and disagreed, politely, about how that approval should happen at all.

Steven Levine, nominated to the Republican seat on the Securities and Exchange Commission that opened when Hester Peirce’s term expired, defended the agency’s habit of moving first by exemption and writing permanent rules later. He reminded senators that the exchange-traded fund itself, the wrapper now holding tens of billions of dollars of Bitcoin, in his words “began as a series of exemptive orders that ultimately resulted in agency rulemaking.” Kristin Johnson, the Democrat tapped to replace Caroline Crenshaw, pushed the other way. “I feel strongly that regulation is made better through the notice-and-comment period,” she told the committee.

That small disagreement is, in miniature, the whole story of how crypto ETFs get approved. Almost nothing about the machine that put spot Bitcoin, Ether, Solana, XRP and a lengthening list of other tokens into ordinary brokerage accounts was built through the slow, formal rulemaking most people picture when they imagine a regulator at work. It was assembled from exemptions, delegated staff orders, a fast-track listing standard, a lost court case and a set of side doors cut through a statute written in 1940. This is a guide to how that machine actually works, why it can wave through a new fund in weeks rather than years, and why even the people who built it keep saying it still needs a rulebook it does not yet have.

The timing is awkward. The approval pipeline has never been smoother, yet 2026 is shaping up to be the first calendar year that US spot Bitcoin funds end with net money walking out the door, a reversal we traced in the machine’s first bear market. Frictionless approval and fading demand have arrived at the same time.

The hearing that framed the question

The 19 November session was a nomination hearing, not a confirmation vote, and by Washington standards it was short and largely free of drama. The White House sent four names to the Senate on 12 November: Johnson and Levine for the SEC, and Nathan Anonick and Matthew Rowland for the Commodity Futures Trading Commission, the agency that regulates the futures markets sitting underneath most crypto ETFs. The Senate Banking Committee will now weigh the nominees and decide whether to advance them to a full-floor vote.

Why a routine hearing matters for ETF investors comes down to arithmetic. The SEC is designed to seat five commissioners. For most of the autumn it has had two, Chair Paul Atkins and Mark Uyeda, after Peirce’s and Crenshaw’s terms ran out. Two is a bare quorum with no margin: a single recusal can freeze a contested vote. Yet funds kept getting approved anyway, because most crypto-ETF approvals no longer require the commissioners to vote at all. The hearing was the first real public glimpse of the people who might restore a full Commission, and of how they think about the shortcuts that kept the agency moving while it was half-empty.

Senator Catherine Cortez Masto pressed both SEC nominees on whether prediction-market firms are effectively offering security-based swaps dressed up as equity-style perpetual futures. Levine declined to stake out a position; Johnson called the jurisdictional line “very critical and important questions.” The exchange was a reminder that the boundary between what the SEC controls and what the CFTC controls, the same boundary that decides which crypto ETFs can exist, is still being drawn case by case.

What approval actually means

An exchange-traded fund is a wrapper. It holds an asset, in this case a crypto token sitting with a custodian, and it issues shares that trade on a stock exchange all day like any other equity. The appeal is plumbing: an investor buys exposure to Bitcoin through a normal brokerage account, inside a retirement plan, with familiar tax forms and no private keys to lose. The self-custody problem of seed phrases and signing apps disappears, replaced by the counterparty problem of who holds the coins on the fund’s behalf.

Getting that wrapper listed in the United States normally takes two separate filings running on two separate tracks inside the SEC. The exchange that wants to list the fund (NYSE Arca, Nasdaq or Cboe BZX) files a Form 19b-4, a proposed rule change arguing that the product is consistent with investor protection; that document is handled by the Division of Trading and Markets. Separately, the fund’s sponsor files a registration statement, usually an S-1, describing the product in detail; that one is reviewed by the Division of Corporation Finance. A fund can only begin trading once the exchange rule change is approved and the registration statement is effective.

Historically the 19b-4 track carried a statutory clock of up to 240 days, and for years the SEC used every day of it before saying no. The entire 2025 and 2026 reform effort was about shrinking, bypassing or automating that clock. Understanding each shortcut is the key to understanding why a product that was impossible in 2023 can now reach the market almost on a schedule.

A decade of no, then a court said yes

The first serious spot Bitcoin ETF proposal, from Cameron and Tyler Winklevoss, was rejected in 2017. Over the next six years the SEC turned down essentially every spot filing that reached it, while allowing Bitcoin futures ETFs such as the ProShares BITO to launch in October 2021 on the theory that futures traded on a regulated exchange were easier to police. The agency’s stated worry was market manipulation: it was not satisfied that the underlying spot market was resistant to fraud.

The delay had a geography to it. While the US stalled, Canada launched North America’s first spot Bitcoin ETF in early 2021, and European investors were already trading physically backed crypto exchange-traded products. US regulators watched listings and order flow move offshore for three years, which became part of Grayscale’s argument: the SEC’s stance was not just internally inconsistent, it was nudging American investors toward venues with weaker oversight.

The wall came down in court, not at the Commission. When the SEC blocked Grayscale from converting its Bitcoin Trust into an ETF while allowing futures products, Grayscale sued. In August 2023 the US Court of Appeals for the D.C. Circuit ruled the denial “arbitrary and capricious,” holding that the agency had failed to explain why a futures product was acceptable but a spot product with the same underlying surveillance was not. The SEC did not choose to open the gate; a panel of judges told it that its reason for keeping the gate shut did not hold up.

January 2024: the gate opens with a disclaimer

On 10 January 2024 the SEC approved eleven spot Bitcoin ETFs at once, and they began trading the next day. The chair at the time went out of his way to drain the moment of enthusiasm, writing in an accompanying statement that the agency “did not approve or endorse Bitcoin” and describing it as a primarily speculative and volatile asset associated with illicit finance. Gary Gensler’s message was that the approvals were a grudging response to a court, not a change of heart. Spot Ether ETFs followed on 23 July 2024, and the template was set: the SEC would permit the wrapper while keeping its distance from the asset inside it.

The surveillance key and the commodity question

Underneath every spot-crypto approval sits one question: is the token a commodity or a security? If it is a commodity, like Bitcoin, the SEC’s traditional test for a commodity-trust ETP applies, and the decisive factor is whether the fund’s listing exchange has a surveillance-sharing agreement with a regulated market of significant size that trades the same asset. For Bitcoin and Ether, the Chicago Mercantile Exchange’s CFTC-regulated futures market supplied exactly that: a venue large enough and well-policed enough to let the SEC argue that manipulation affecting the ETF could be detected. The Intermarket Surveillance Group, a cross-market body that shares trading data, is the plumbing behind that assurance.

This is why the commodity-or-security line is the master key to the whole system, and why the CFTC nominees at the 19 November hearing matter as much as the SEC ones. A token that the SEC treats as a security cannot slot into the commodity-trust template at all; it has to clear a different, far harder path. The slow, grinding work of 2025 and 2026 was, at bottom, an effort to answer the commodity-or-security question for dozens of tokens at once, so the ETF wrapper could be bolted on without a separate fight each time.

Generic listing standards: approval without approval

The single most important change arrived on 17 September 2025, when the SEC approved generic listing standards for commodity-based trust shares, crypto included, proposed by NYSE Arca, Nasdaq and Cboe BZX. The mechanism is deceptively simple: if a proposed crypto ETP meets a defined set of criteria, the exchange can list and trade it without a separate SEC approval for each fund. The 240-day review that once killed filings shrinks to a listing decision measured in weeks.

To qualify under the standards, as the law firm Dechert laid out, the fund’s underlying asset generally has to clear one of three tests: it trades on a market that is a member of the Intermarket Surveillance Group with surveillance access; or it underlies a futures contract listed for at least six months on a CFTC-regulated designated contract market with a surveillance-sharing agreement; or it is already held at 40 percent or more of net asset value by an existing US-listed ETF. Meet one, and the fast lane opens.

There is a telling detail in how the standards themselves were adopted. The order that approved them was framed, in part, as setting aside an action taken by delegated authority and approving the change at the Commission level, because the Division of Trading and Markets had first signed off under delegated authority before the commissioners pulled the matter up to decide it themselves. Delegated authority, the power of SEC staff to act in the Commission’s name without a vote, is the quiet engine of the entire approval machine. It is how a two-member SEC can keep clearing funds.

RouteHow it worksTypical timeline
Individual 19b-4 plus S-1Exchange files a rule change, sponsor files registration; both reviewed case by caseUp to 240 days
Generic listing standardsFund meets defined criteria; exchange lists with no separate SEC approvalWeeks
1940-Act side doorFund registers under the 1940 Act, often as a C-corp, skipping the 19b-4 trackMonths, no 19b-4 vote
Exemptive orderSEC grants conditional relief for a product type, with permanent rules to follow laterAt the agency’s discretion
The four ways a crypto investment product reaches US markets, from slowest to most discretionary.

Not everyone at the Commission was comfortable. In a dissent pointedly titled “Passing the Buck,” Commissioner Crenshaw argued the agency was handing off its own review duty and rushing “new and arguably unproven products” to market, warning that investors might assume protections the wrapper does not actually provide. Her seat is the one Johnson has now been nominated to fill, which is why her objection echoed through the November hearing: the Democrat picked to replace her was making a version of the same argument, that big decisions belong in notice-and-comment rulemaking, not in staff orders.

The side doors: a 1940 statute, a C-corp and in-kind

The generic standards fast-tracked plain spot funds, but issuers found another way around the 19b-4 track for products the standards did not cover. Rather than list as a commodity trust, a sponsor can register the fund under the Investment Company Act of 1940, the statute that governs mutual funds, frequently structuring it as a taxable C-corporation. That path carries its own costs and tax drag, but it sidesteps the exchange-rule-change vote altogether.

This side door produced the first wave of products the old regime would never have cleared. The REX-Osprey SOL and Staking ETF, known as SSK, launched around 2 July 2025 as the first US ETF to hold a token and stake it, using the 1940-Act structure to avoid the 19b-4 process. The first Dogecoin ETF, DOJE, arrived on 18 September 2025 using a 1940-Act fund with a Cayman subsidiary. These were not approvals in the grand, eleven-funds-at-once sense; they were clever uses of an existing statute by sponsors who no longer had to ask the Commission for a bespoke rule change.

The SEC greased the machine from its side too. On 29 July 2025 it permitted in-kind creations and redemptions for crypto ETPs, letting authorized participants swap the underlying coins directly for fund shares rather than moving cash in and out. It was a technical change with real consequences for tax efficiency and tracking, and it was delivered the way almost everything here is delivered: by order, not by a fresh rule written from scratch.

The staking question the SEC had to answer

Once funds started holding proof-of-stake tokens, a new question arrived: if the fund stakes its coins and earns a yield, is that yield a securities transaction? The answer came on 17 March 2026, when the SEC and CFTC issued a joint interpretation sorting common crypto activities into categories and treating staking, mining and airdrops as falling outside the securities laws. That cleared the way for ETFs to stake openly and pass the rewards into net asset value, turning an inert spot fund into a yield-bearing one.

Where that yield comes from is not magic; it is the same validator economics that powers the liquid-staking protocols retail users rely on, now wrapped in a fund. The newest examples keep arriving even as prices fall: the Canary Staked INJ ETF, ticker INJC, launched on Nasdaq on 5 November 2026 as the first US spot ETF to hold and stake Injective’s token, auto-restaking most of its holdings. A down market has not slowed the product pipeline, because the pipeline no longer depends on a bullish Commission approving each fund by hand.

Who signs off now: two commissioners and delegated staff

Here is the part that surprises people. Through most of autumn 2026, the agency approving America’s crypto ETFs has had exactly two sitting commissioners. Peirce, who ran the SEC’s Crypto Task Force, left when her term expired; Crenshaw’s term lapsed as well. That leaves Atkins and Uyeda, a bare quorum. If the agency still needed a full commissioner vote to list each fund, the pipeline would have stalled months ago.

It did not stall, because the architecture described above was designed, deliberately or not, to run without a full house. Generic listing standards push the decision down to the exchanges. Delegated authority lets staff act for the Commission. The 1940-Act path avoids the 19b-4 vote. Add them up and a two-person SEC can keep approving funds almost indefinitely, which is precisely what has happened. That autonomy is also the system’s weak point: it concentrates enormous discretion in staff and in whichever two commissioners remain, with little of the public deliberation a rulemaking forces into the open.

The 12 November nominations are the attempt to refill the bench. If the Senate confirms Johnson and Levine, the SEC moves back toward its full complement, and the exemption-versus-rulemaking argument they aired at the hearing stops being theoretical. A Commission with five members and a Democratic voice has more capacity, and more pressure, either to convert the pile of orders and exemptions into durable rules or to leave the fast machine running as it is.

The plumbing behind the ticker: custody, participants and fees

Approval is only the visible half. Behind each ticker is a chain of service providers, and it is more concentrated than the long list of fund names suggests. Authorized participants, the large banks and market makers, do the actual creating and redeeming of shares, arbitraging the fund’s price toward the value of its coins. Custody is where the concentration bites: Coinbase holds roughly 80 percent or more of the crypto sitting inside US spot ETFs, a single point of failure that choosing a different fund does little to diversify. Fidelity’s FBTC is the notable self-custodian; most of the rest lean on the same small set of custodians.

That creation and redemption cycle is also what keeps an ETF’s market price glued to the value of its holdings. When shares trade richer than the coins inside, authorized participants create new ones and sell them; when shares trade cheaper, they redeem. The 2025 in-kind change made that loop more efficient by letting the swaps happen in Bitcoin rather than cash, trimming the tax and tracking friction that cash-only creation introduced. For the investor it is invisible, but it is the reason a spot ETF rarely strays far from the price of the asset it tracks.

Fees are the one arena where competition has been brutal. When Grayscale converted its legacy trust into GBTC in January 2024 it kept a 1.50 percent expense ratio, six times its cheapest rivals, and has bled assets to lower-cost funds ever since. The table below shows the spread, and the gap matters more than it looks over a multi-year hold, before you even reach the tax questions covered in our year-end tax playbook.

Fund (ticker)SponsorExpense ratioPrimary custodian
iShares Bitcoin Trust (IBIT)BlackRock0.25%Coinbase
Fidelity Wise Origin (FBTC)Fidelity0.25%Fidelity Digital Assets
Grayscale Bitcoin Trust (GBTC)Grayscale1.50%Coinbase
Grayscale Bitcoin Mini (BTC)Grayscale0.15%Coinbase
Bitwise Bitcoin (BITB)Bitwise0.20%Coinbase
ARK 21Shares (ARKB)ARK / 21Shares0.21%Coinbase
Fee and custody snapshot for the largest US spot Bitcoin ETFs; ratios are published headline figures and some carry temporary waivers.

The machine meets its first down year

The frictionless approval system was built during a bull market and is now being tested by its opposite. As of 19 November 2026 Bitcoin was trading near $63,000, down from its $126,198 record set in October 2025, with Ether below $1,800 and the Fear and Greed Index pinned at 10, deep in extreme-fear territory. That drawdown, and the question of where a floor might sit, is the subject of our look at Bitcoin’s production cost.

The flows tell the story bluntly. US spot Bitcoin ETFs have swung to more than $1.1 billion in net outflows for 2026, according to Cointribune’s tally, after showing roughly $1.43 billion of inflows just three weeks earlier, a swing near $2.5 billion. Six of November’s first seven sessions ended red, shedding about $1.58 billion, and even BlackRock’s IBIT, still positive by about $2.7 billion on the year, gave back $1.66 billion across seven straight withdrawal days from 30 October. If the year ends here, 2026 will be the first negative calendar year since the funds launched in January 2024.

Date or periodUS spot BTC ETF flowsWhat it showed
13 July 2026 (trough)2026 cumulative near -$5.7 billionSummer outflow low
20 October 20262026 cumulative about +$1.43 billionBack in the black
Early November 2026Flipped to roughly -$1.0 billion for the yearMomentum reversed
First week of NovemberAbout -$1.58 billion across six of seven daysSustained exits
Mid-November 2026More than -$1.1 billion for the yearOn track for a first losing year
The 2026 round-trip from deep outflows to brief inflows and back; figures are net-flow estimates compiled from Cointribune, CoinCodex and fund trackers.

The lesson is that approval and demand are different machines. The SEC can make it trivial to launch a fund; it cannot make anyone buy it. For most of 2024 and 2025 the two moved together, which made the approval story look like a demand story. In the 2026 drawdown they have split: new products such as INJC keep listing into a falling market, while money leaves the flagship funds. A smooth assembly line can still produce goods nobody wants that week.

Tokenization: the next thing built by exemption

The argument at the November hearing was not really about ETFs; it was about what comes next, and whether the next thing should be built the same way. On 17 September 2026 the SEC issued what it calls an innovation exemption for tokenized securities, a five-year conditional order running to September 2031 that lets approved “tokenized securities venues” offer on-chain trading of tokenized US-listed stocks through automated market makers without registering as exchanges. It was granted, as the law firm Sidley noted, by exemptive order under Section 36(a)(1) of the Securities Exchange Act, with symbol and volume caps and no leverage, not by rulemaking.

Even Chair Atkins frames the exemption as temporary scaffolding, saying it “must be followed by durable rulemaking.” That is the thread connecting tokenized stocks back to the ETF: the same institution reaches for a conditional order to let a market form, and promises the permanent rulebook later. The tokenization of real-world assets, from Treasuries to equities, is the subject of our deeper look at Wall Street’s on-chain pipe, and it is being assembled brick by brick out of the same exemptions that built the crypto ETF.

Johnson’s complaint at the hearing was that this habit has limits. An exemption can be revoked, narrowed or left to expire; it does not carry the legal durability or the public record of a rule that survived notice and comment. Levine’s rejoinder, that the ETF itself grew from exactly this kind of order into settled practice, is the optimistic case: start with scaffolding, let the market prove itself, codify what works. The honest answer is that the crypto ETF has not actually reached the codification step. It still runs on orders.

What still cannot be rubber-stamped

The fast lane is wide but not unlimited. The generic listing standards deliberately exclude several categories: leveraged and inverse products, actively managed funds, and structures that lend, rehypothecate or share revenue from the underlying coins. A 3x leveraged single-token ETF or an actively managed basket still has to travel the slower individual path or lean on a derivatives-based 1940-Act structure, because those designs carry risks the blanket criteria were never meant to wave through. The exemptions that made plain spot funds trivial stop at the edge of the plain spot fund.

The frontier is also where the commodity-or-security question gets sharpest. Tokens with active development teams, ongoing token sales or governance that looks like a management role are harder to slot into the commodity template, which is why the 2026 joint interpretation and the pending Regulation Crypto Assets proposal matter so much to the next wave of filings. Each one is an attempt to answer, in advance and in bulk, the question the ETF machine needs settled before it can run.

So what should an investor actually watch? Three things. First, whether the Senate confirms Johnson, Levine and the two CFTC nominees, restoring a full Commission and with it the capacity to turn orders into rules. Second, whether the SEC and CFTC convert any of their exemptions and joint interpretations into formal, noticed rulemakings, the step that would make the current regime durable rather than reversible. Third, the flows: an approval system running at full speed into a market that keeps redeeming is a very different story from the 2024 boom, and 2026’s first losing year is the early evidence of which way the wind is blowing.

The machine that approves crypto ETFs is, for now, a marvel of regulatory improvisation: fast, flexible and capable of running on two commissioners and a stack of delegated orders. Whether that counts as a feature or a fragility is exactly what the two nominees were arguing about on 19 November, and it is a question the market, not just the Senate, will help answer in 2027.

Frequently Asked Questions

How long does it take to approve a crypto ETF now?

For a plain spot fund that meets the generic listing standards the SEC adopted in September 2025, listing can happen in a matter of weeks rather than the up-to-240-day review that applied before. The exchange lists the product once it meets the criteria, with no separate SEC approval vote for each fund. Leveraged, inverse or actively managed products are excluded from that fast lane and still face a slower, individual review.

Who actually approves a crypto ETF at the SEC?

Two divisions handle the paperwork: Trading and Markets reviews the exchange’s 19b-4 rule change, and Corporation Finance reviews the sponsor’s registration statement. Increasingly the decisions are made by staff under delegated authority rather than by a vote of the commissioners, which is how a two-member Commission has kept approving funds through late 2026. The commissioners can still pull a matter up to decide it themselves.

Why are Bitcoin ETFs seeing outflows in 2026?

Approval and demand are separate forces. Prices fell hard from the October 2025 record, sentiment turned to extreme fear, and investors pulled money even as new funds kept launching. US spot Bitcoin ETFs moved to more than $1.1 billion in net outflows for 2026, which would make it the first negative calendar year since the funds began trading in January 2024.

What is the difference between the generic listing standards and an exemptive order?

Generic listing standards are approved exchange rules that let any fund meeting fixed criteria list without a case-by-case SEC approval. An exemptive order is conditional relief the SEC grants for a product type, such as the 2026 tokenization exemption, that lets a market operate for a set period while permanent rules are written later. Both avoid full notice-and-comment rulemaking, which is the point of contention among the SEC’s current nominees.

Can you get a Solana, XRP or staking ETF in the US?

Yes. Spot Solana, XRP and Litecoin ETFs began trading in late 2025 under the new standards, and staking versions followed after the March 2026 SEC-CFTC interpretation placed staking outside the securities laws. The Canary Staked INJ ETF for Injective, ticker INJC, launched on Nasdaq on 5 November 2026 as one of the newest examples, holding and staking the token inside the fund.

Anneke de Vries is a regulation correspondent at HOGE Wire, covering market structure, the SEC and the mechanics of crypto investment products.

Share 𝕏 Post Telegram